home 
24 Feb. 2025 by Which Solution is Right for You?
The choice between Managed SOC, MDR, and SIEM ultimately depends on your organisation’s specific needs, resources, and goals. If you’re looking for a comprehensive solution that delivers 24/7 monitoring, threat hunting, and incident response, a Managed SOC is the clear choice. For organisations with more limited needs, MDR may be a better fit. And if you have the in-house expertise to manage it, SIEM can be a powerful tool for log aggregation and compliance reporting.
For enterprise organisations, the ROI of a SOC makes it an attractive option. By outsourcing to a Managed SOC, you can strengthen your cybersecurity while controlling costs and reducing operational overhead.
In today’s rapidly evolving cybersecurity landscape, enterprise organisations face an unprecedented volume of threats. From ransomware attacks to sophisticated phishing campaigns, the stakes have never been higher. For IT teams, the challenge lies not only in detecting and responding to these threats but also in ensuring that their security infrastructure delivers a strong return on investment (ROI). This is where solutions like Managed SOC (Security Operations Centre), MDR (Managed Detection and Response), and SIEM (Security Information and Event Management) can help. But how do you decide which one is right for your organisation?
Understanding the Key Solutions: Managed SOC, MDR, and SIEM
Before looking more deeply into the comparisons, it’s important to understand what each solution offers and how they differ.
Managed SOC (Security Operations Centre)
A Managed SOC is a fully outsourced service that provides 24/7 monitoring, threat detection, and incident response. It combines advanced technology with human expertise to proactively defend against cyber threats. SOC outsourcing allows organisations to leverage a team of security analysts, threat hunters, and incident responders without the need to build and maintain an in-house team. This is particularly appealing for enterprises looking to enhance their security posture while controlling costs.
MDR (Managed Detection and Response)
MDR is a more focused service that combines technology and human expertise to detect and respond to threats in real-time. Unlike a Managed SOC, MDR typically relies on the vendor’s proprietary tools and platforms. It’s a good fit for organisations that need rapid threat detection and response but may not require the comprehensive monitoring and analysis provided by a SOC.
SIEM (Security Information and Event Management)
SIEM is a technology platform that aggregates and analyses log data from across an organisation’s IT infrastructure. It provides real-time analysis of security alerts and helps with compliance reporting. However, SIEM tools require significant configuration, tuning, and expertise to operate effectively. While powerful, they are not a standalone solution and often need to be complemented with human oversight.
Managed SOC vs MDR vs SIEM: Key Differences
When comparing SIEM vs MDR vs SOC, it’s essential to consider the scope, capabilities, and operational requirements of each solution.
- Scope of Coverage : A Managed SOC offers the broadest scope, providing end-to-end security monitoring, threat hunting, and incident response. MDR, on the other hand, focuses primarily on detection and response, often using a narrower set of tools. SIEM is a technology platform that requires additional resources to deliver actionable insights.
- Human Expertise: Both Managed SOC and MDR services include human expertise, but the level of involvement differs. A Managed SOC typically offers a dedicated team of analysts, while MDR may rely on shared resources. SIEM, being a tool, requires in-house expertise to manage and interpret the data.
- Operational Overhead: SOC outsourcing eliminates the need for organisations to build and maintain their own security operations centre, making it a cost-effective option for many enterprises. MDR reduces operational overhead but may not provide the same level of comprehensive monitoring. SIEM, while powerful, often requires significant investment in both technology and skilled personnel.
ROI of a SOC
The ROI of a SOC is often higher for organisations that need continuous monitoring and rapid incident response. By outsourcing to a Managed SOC, enterprises can avoid the high costs associated with building and staffing an in-house team while still benefiting from enterprise-grade security.
Perhaps you’ve experienced these pain points:
When to Choose a Managed SOC?
A Managed SOC is ideal for organisations that:
- Require 24/7 monitoring and threat detection.
- Lack the resources or expertise to build and maintain an in-house SOC.
- Need a comprehensive solution that covers threat hunting, incident response, and vulnerability management.
- Want to improve their security posture while controlling costs through SOC outsourcing.
For example, a large enterprise with a complex IT infrastructure and strict compliance requirements would benefit significantly from a Managed SOC. The ability to detect and respond to threats in real-time, combined with the expertise of a dedicated team, ensures that the organisation is always one step ahead of cybercriminals.
When to Choose MDR?
MDR is a better fit for organisations that:
- Need rapid threat detection and response but have limited resources.
- Prefer a solution that relies on the vendor’s proprietary tools and platforms.
- Do not require the full scope of services provided by a Managed SOC.
- MDR is often chosen by mid-sized enterprises that need to enhance their security capabilities without the complexity of managing a full SOC.
When to Choose SIEM?
SIEM is suitable for organisations that:
- Have the in-house expertise to manage and interpret SIEM data.
- Need a tool for log aggregation, compliance reporting, and real-time alerting.
- Are willing to invest in additional resources to complement the SIEM platform.
While SIEM is a powerful tool, it is not a standalone solution. Organisations that choose SIEM often pair it with other services, such as a Managed SOC or MDR, to achieve a comprehensive security posture.
The ROI of a SOC: Why Managed SOC Makes Sense?
One of the most compelling reasons to choose a Managed SOC is the ROI it delivers. Building and maintaining an in-house SOC requires significant investment in technology, infrastructure, and personnel. For many organisations, this is simply not feasible. SOC outsourcing allows enterprises to access the same level of expertise and technology at a fraction of the cost.
Additionally, a Managed SOC provides continuous monitoring and rapid incident response, reducing the risk of costly breaches. By detecting and mitigating threats early, organisations can avoid the financial and reputational damage associated with cyberattacks. This makes the ROI of a SOC particularly attractive for enterprises looking to strengthen their cybersecurity without breaking the bank.
Why Threatproof’s Managed SOC Stands Out?
At Threatproof, we understand the challenges faced by IT teams in enterprise organisations. Our Managed SOC is designed to provide comprehensive security monitoring, threat detection, and incident response, all delivered by a team of experienced security professionals. With 24/7 coverage and advanced analytics, we ensure that your organisation is always protected.
By choosing Threatproof’s Managed SOC, you can:
- Enhance your security posture with enterprise-grade protection.
- Reduce operational overhead through SOC outsourcing.
- Achieve a strong ROI by avoiding the costs of building and maintaining an in-house SOC.
At Threatproof, we’re committed to helping enterprise organisations stay ahead of cyber threats also with our Infinite Security TM service.
To learn more about our Managed SOC and how it can benefit your organisation, contact us today.
© Copyright 2025. Threatproof. All rights reserved.
